LSD Increases Primary Process Thinking

By David Jenison on January 30, 2018

Frontier in Pharmacology recently published a study by Swiss and German researchers who argued that lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) increases primary process thinking. So what does that mean? 

Primary process is part of an early meta-psychological theory posited by Sigmund Freud, and the researchers described it as follows: "There exist two distinct modes of psychic functioning: primary process and secondary process. It is broadly believed that... secondary process is a hierarchically higher-level cognitive mode which fulfills an adaptive, reflective, rule-bound function and thus inhibits lower-level, automatic, motivation- and emotion-driven primary process. Under altered psychophysiological conditions such as dreaming, hypnosis, meditation, sensory deprivation, respiratory maneuvers, trance, psychosis, and epilepsy, primary process may become the prevailing cognitive mode."

Psychedelics "activate mental processes which are closely related to primary process, such as vivid, dreamlike imagery, basic emotions, and bizarre thinking," and previous studies suggest that LSD stimulates 5-HT2A receptors, which in turn increases primary process. The European researchers sought to test the connection between LSD, primary process and 5-HT2A activation. 

For the study, 19 men and six women between the ages of 20 and 34 took either 1) LSD, 2) a placebo, or 3) LSD + ketanserin. The latter drug is a 5-HT2A antagonist that would block LSD-induced activation of the serotonin-class receptor, thus testing its role in increasing primary process. Seven hours after receiving the dosage, the participants then took a 30-minute mental imagery task measured by primary index (including symbolism, visual representation, unlikely combinations) and the Altered State of Consciousness rating scale (spiritual experience, blissful state, disembodiment). What happened? 

Compared with the placebo, LSD increased primary process thinking and correlated with an altered state of consciousness. Alternatively, those who took LSD and ketanserin together experienced none of these effects. This suggests the 5-HT2A antagonist blocked the increase in primary process, thus reconfirming the idea that activating the receptor with LSD does account for the increase. 

Per the researchers, "The main finding of this study was that LSD increased primary process thinking, a lower-level, automatic, motivation- and emotion-driven mode of mental organization which is characterized by image fusion; unlikely combinations or events; sudden shifts or transformations of images; and contradictory or illogical actions, feelings, or thoughts…. Furthermore, we found that the effect of LSD on primary index was completely blocked by ketanserin."

The study also found that "secondary process thinking during psychedelic states appears preserved" while noting other studies that suggest psychedelics increase neural activity in cortical areas of the brain. "Therefore," the study argued,"psychedelic states may be best conceptualized as hybrid states of consciousness which share features of both dreaming and waking consciousness."

Based on this additional finding, the researchers added, "The close neurophenomenological similarity between psychedelic states and lucid dreaming may shed some light on the therapeutic potential of psychedelic-induced experiences: They… induce conscious learning experiences that promote self-knowledge and psychological insight."

Several studies suggest that patients with treatment-resistant mental health disorders often experience breakthroughs when therapies are paired with psychedelics. The current study ultimately asks the question, does increased primary process thinking play a role in these breakthroughs? 

Image credit: Ron English

Researcher Reverses Herself on Landmark Cannabis-Harm Claim

Why You Should Leave Extraction to the Pros

More Studies Claim Cannabis Reduces Opioid Use

This Drugged-Driving Study Might Surprise You

P. Harmala, the Healing Hallucinogenic Threatening Big Pharma

Major Study Suggests CBD Can Help with Psychosis

Stop the Shakes: Cannabis and Parkinson’s

Most Lit Cannabis Song Per Year in the 2000s

Most Lit Cannabis Song Per Year in the 2010s

The Cannabis Condom: It’s Only a Matter of Time

Study Says Let Grandma Smoke!

2,588 Patients Have Something to Say about MMJ

Fox News Poll Shows Record Support for Legalization!

FDA Declares Kratom an Opioid

9 Ways Vienna Is Weird AF